About Exchange Flow

How We Rate

The criteria behind every score on Exchange Flow, where our facts come from and how often we check them.

Updated on October 4, 2026

At a glance

Six criteria, one overall score

The six exchange criteria with the scores from our Kraken review as an example, and how the overall score comes about for each kind of provider.

Exchanges and brokers, example: Kraken

  • OperationThis evaluates the ease of daily platform use, including account setup, interface clarity and modernity, and the speed at which primary functions can be located.
  • Functions and scopeThis covers the platform's offerings, from spot trading to derivatives, margin, staking, savings plans, and tools for active traders.
  • Fees and costsThis examines the cost of trading and its form.
  • Security and trustThis reflects the platform's public signals of user protection, including security features like two-factor authentication, certifications, audits, the company behind the platform, its reputation, and track record.
  • Beginner friendlinessThis measures how straightforward it is for someone new to crypto to begin, starting from account opening to making an initial purchase and locating main functions.
  • SupportHow good customer support is and how easy it is to reach.
  • Our overall score is an editorial judgment, not the average of the six.Plain average8.2Overall

Scores from our Kraken review

How the overall score comes about

  • Exchanges and brokers6 criteriaOne segment per criterion. Outlined: no fixed weight.

    On most exchange and broker reviews, the overall score is higher than the plain average of the six sub-scores, by up to 1.5 points.

  • Instant swaps7 criteriaOne segment per criterion. Outlined: no fixed weight.

    For instant swaps, it stays close to the average of the seven sub-scores but is not tied to it: the largest gap is 0.4 points.

Our ratings in short

Every exchange, broker, wallet, and instant swap service reviewed by us receives a score ranging from 1 to 10 across various criteria, along with an overall score. These scores are editorially determined by our editors based on publicly available information about each provider. They represent opinions, not investment guidance.

We check the facts next to the scores, such as fees, the number of coins, licenses and where a service is available, against the provider's own pages and public registers. We record each fact we check with its source and the date of the check.

Exchange Flow is reader-supported. We may earn a commission when you sign up through our links. Commissions do not influence our ratings or rankings. Visitor reviews, displayed as stars out of 5, are distinct from our scores.

What we score on exchange and broker reviews

Each exchange and broker review is broken down into six sub-scores from 1 to 10. Here's what each sub-score covers and which facts in the review pertain to it.

Operation

This evaluates the ease of daily platform use, including account setup, interface clarity and modernity, and the speed at which primary functions can be located. The review fact associated with this is the account opening duration.

Functions and scope

This covers the platform's offerings, from spot trading to derivatives, margin, Interest can be earned through "staking" by "freezing" a certain number of cryptocurrencies for a defined period of time. The interest is generated from the consensus algorithm (e.g. "proof of stake"), which is used to validate and secure the network., savings plans, and tools for active traders. Related facts include the number of cryptocurrencies, feature overview, tradable assets, and trading options.

Fees and costs

This examines the cost of trading and its form. We analyze the level and type of fees, such as maker and taker fees or spreads, as well as costs that might be overlooked. Related facts are the trading fee for a new account and the Bitcoin withdrawal fee. Our fee table presents these side by side.

Security and trust

This reflects the platform's public signals of user protection, including security features like Two-factor authentication (2FA) is an additional measure to improve the protection and security of user accounts: In addition to the password, a second security component must be entered when logging in, e.g. a PIN code., certifications, audits, the company behind the platform, its reputation, and track record. Related facts include two-factor authentication, deposit protection, the operating company, and its headquarters.

Licenses and registrations are listed as facts in each review. Under our editorial policies, they are not included in the scores, so check them directly if regulation is a concern for you. If you reside in the US, our list for US customers shows which exchanges operate in which states.

Beginner friendliness

This measures how straightforward it is for someone new to crypto to begin, starting from account opening to making an initial purchase and locating main functions. Related facts include the platform's suitability, minimum deposit, and payment methods.

Support

How good customer support is and how easy it is to reach. To keep this rating balanced, we also take into account what users report on other platforms, such as app stores and review sites.

How the overall score works

The overall score of an exchange or broker is our editorial judgment of the platform as a whole. It draws from the six sub-scores but is not their average and has no fixed weights.

On most exchange and broker reviews, the overall score is higher than the plain average of the six sub-scores, by up to 1.5 points.

For wallets, the overall score is the plain average of the six sub-scores, rounded to one decimal place. For instant swaps, it stays close to the average of the seven sub-scores but is not tied to it: the largest gap is 0.4 points.

Scores change only by an editorial decision. When a fact we record contradicts a score, for example after a fee increase, we log it for that decision. A new fact never changes a score on its own.

Wallets and instant swaps

Wallet reviews also feature six sub-scores: operation, functions and scope, supported assets, security and trust, beginner friendliness, and support. Supported assets covers the number of coins and tokens a wallet manages and the types of assets, like NFTs. Related facts in a wallet review include whether the code is open source, whether you hold the The so-called "private key" is a unique sequence of numbers and characters and the private key that gives you direct access to and control over your cryptocurrencies. The private key is used to sign transactions. In simple terms, it can be seen as a digital fingerprint that proves that you are the owner of the cryptocurrencies. If you store your cryptocurrencies on so-called "custodial wallets" (e.g. crypto exchanges), you are not the owner of your private keys., the secure element, the backup method, and the price.

Instant swap reviews score seven criteria: anonymity, user interface, refund policy, transaction speed, customer service, features, and fees. Anonymity reflects the amount of personal information a service requests, and the refund policy outlines what happens if a swap fails or is halted.

Where our facts come from

We check facts at primary sources: the provider's own fee schedules, terms of use, help pages and announcements, and the public registers kept by regulators. We store each fact we check with its source, a short quote and the date of the check. When we change a value on the site, we keep the old value, the source and the check date in a change log.

A few rules apply across the site:

  • We use the figure provided by the provider, such as a withdrawal fee, when stated.
  • Bitcoin network fees change by the minute, so we show "Varies" with a note. The note provides the provider's stated amount or, if unavailable, a dated estimate with a range.
  • The headquarters and flag next to a provider correspond to the operating company named in its terms, not an earlier or assumed location.

How often we check

Facts that change often, such as fees, availability, status and coin counts, count as current for 30 days. Company facts, such as the founding year or the headquarters, count as current for 180 days. Before we write or revise a review or a comparison, we check any older fact again at the source. Network fee estimates are fetched again on the day we update a page.

Before we mark a closure, a pause or a limit on a review, we confirm the change at a primary source. The Updated on line of a page indicates when we last revised the page as a whole. Smaller corrections in between, such as a fee, a status or a single sentence, may not change that date.

Closed, paused and restricted providers

When a provider's status changes, its review displays a brief status line under its name: Closed, Closing, Paused, or Restricted for exchanges, and Discontinued for wallet models no longer sold. Open the details to see what changed, the date we checked it, and, if available, the source.

A closed or closing exchange exits every ranked list on Exchange Flow. Its review remains online as a record, without a sign-up bonus or partner link, and its visit button directs to the status details instead of the provider. Its last scores remain visible for reference. Paused and restricted providers stay in our lists, and their reviews carry the status line, so you can see the limits before you sign up. Discontinued wallets maintain their review, marked as discontinued.

User ratings from app stores

Many of our reviews show a block called What users say elsewhere. It lists the average rating and the number of ratings of the provider's app in the US App Store and in the US view of Google Play, each with the date we checked it and a link to the store page. For Google Play, it also shows how the ratings split across one to five stars. We show the figures as each store publishes them, rounded to one decimal place like the store itself, and we do not pick or leave out ratings. For Trustpilot, we show no figures, at most a link to the provider's page, because its terms do not allow us to collect them.

For some providers, we also sum up the themes in the 20 written reviews that Google Play shows first on the app page. Google picks and orders these reviews, and they are often more critical than the star ratings as a whole. So we name the sample, give each theme as a share of it and compare it with all ratings.

These figures do not feed into our scores. Our editors set every score as described above; no store rating, count or share is part of a score, and a new figure never changes a score on its own. For crypto cards and hardware wallets, the ratings cover the app you use with the product, not the product itself.

How we make money

Exchange Flow is free to read. We earn money when you open an account through some of our links, because the provider may then pay us a commission. Not every provider pays us, and some of our links go to the provider's site without a partner code.

Commissions do not influence our ratings or rankings. Our editors set the scores. Our Advertiser Disclosure explains how our partner links function.

Our ratings are not investment advice. Crypto assets are volatile, and you can lose money. Please consider our reviews as one source among several. Our Risk Disclaimer contains the details.

Who writes our reviews

Our reviews and comparisons are written and edited by the Exchange Flow editorial team. Meet Ethan Parker, our Senior Content Editor, and Juli Miller, our Technical Writer and Editor.

Corrections

If you spot an error or an outdated figure, write to [email protected]. We check a report against the primary source before we change anything.

Sources

Our process

Report an error

If you spot an error or an outdated figure, write to contact@exchangeflow.co.